John Davis

Written by John Davis

4 COMMENTS

How Does Running Affect Your Immune System? The Research on Illness, Part II

Last week, we looked at some research on running while sick.

Surprisingly, we found evidence that running when you’ve come down with a minor illness like a cold isn’t such a bad idea.

In fact, it doesn’t seem to change the course of your recovery at all!

But what about getting sick? Does exercise keep you healthier? Or does the wear-and-tear on your body from training make your immune system less effective and you more vulnerable to sickness? That’s the topic we’ll look at today.

The research on the effects of running on the immune system

The first study we’ll examine was published by L. Spence and coworkers in 2007.1

His study looked at the incidence of upper-respiratory infections (e.g. a cold) in three groups of subjects over a five-month period: Elite athletes, recreational athletes, and sedentary control subjects.  When the subjects displayed symptoms of a cold, like a runny nose or a sore throat, the researchers swabbed their mouth and nose to search for viruses.

While they were only modestly successful in actually identifying the viruses that caused the infections in their subjects, the researchers’ data nevertheless showed that the rate of infection was higher both in the elite athletes and in the sedentary subjects when compared to the recreational athletes.

Spence, et al., admitted that the findings of their study were limited because they could not identify the cause of illness in the majority of the cases, but regardless, their findings are important, as it hints that more exercise may not always be better when it comes to preventing illness.

The more significant impact of intense training

A larger study using only runners was published several years earlier by G.W. Heath and co-workers at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.2

In this study, 530 runners kept a monthly log of their training and health for 12 months.  By using the running logs of the subjects, the researchers were able to deduce some of the risk factors for having a higher frequency of upper respiratory infection.  On the whole, the subjects averaged 1.2 upper respiratory infections per year—about one every 10 months.

But the incidence rate varied significantly; people who lived alone, for example, had a much higher incidence rate than those who did not (for unknown reasons). And more relevant to the topic at hand:

Mileage was also correlated with infection risk, with runners logging higher yearly mileage incurring more upper respiratory infections.

This provides further evidence that a higher training load might increase your risk of getting sick.

The mechanism of action identified

A review study by Laurel T Mackinnon of the University of Queensland in Australia attempted to explain why moderate exercise seems to lower your risk of infection while heavier loads seem to increase it.3

Looking at several biological trials studying the effects of an exercise load on the cellular response of the immune system, she demonstrated that moderate exercise has either no effect on or has a small stimulating effect on a range of immune functions, from immunoglobulin levels to “killer cell” activity.

On the other hand, it appears that heavy training impairs the function of these same mechanisms.

In particular, it seems that long sustained periods of intense training over many days or weeks has a deleterious effect on the immune system.

Mackinnon emphasizes that athletes in hard training are in no way immunodeficient, and are still fully capable of fighting off infections and keeping their body healthy.

However, the small but measurable drop in immune function during intense training makes them more vulnerable, statistically speaking, to infectious disease.  This explains the findings of Spence, et al., and Heath, et al.

Light-to-moderate training seems to provide a small protective boost to your immune system.  But as your training becomes more serious, you become somewhat more vulnerable to minor illnesses like the common cold.

The training that constitutes “serious” according to the research consists of fewer miles than you might think. Heath, et al., showed an increased risk of upper-respiratory infection in subjects who ran an average of more than 20 miles per week annually vs. those who averaged less. 

The dearth of studies with high-mileage participants render the risks in athletes logging higher mileage (those training for a marathon, for example) less well-understood.

Final recommendations

Regardless, from what the available studies show, your risk of infection is indeed higher, but is probably nothing to worry excessively about.  Laurel Mackinnon recommends that athletes:

There’s probably not a lot you can do in your daily life to lower your exposure to viruses, except perhaps washing your hands more often, so just be aware that you may come down with a cold more often when you are in heavy training — though when you do, try not to let it slow you down too much! As we saw last week, running easy during a mild or moderate cold doesn’t appear to make it last any longer or get any worse.

Free Run Faster Course

Learn How to Train Smarter and Run Faster Using the Latest Science and Proven Workouts

Here’s what you'll learn in this course

The scientific demands of your race distance so you know exactly how to target your workouts and training.

6 Race specific workouts that will help up you crush your next race

The most common mistakes you're making in training and in your race plan (and how to fix them)

References

1. Spence, L.; Brown, W. J.; Pyne, D. B.; Nissen, M. D.; Sloots, T. P.; McCormack, J. G.; Locke, A. S.; Fricker, P. A., Incidence, etiology, and symptomatology of upper respiratory illness in elite athletes. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 2007, 39 (4), 577-586.
2. Heath, G. W.; Ford, E. S.; Craven, T. E.; Macera, C. A.; Jackson, K. L.; Pate, R. R., Exercise and teh incidence of upper respiratoy tract infections. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 1991, 23 (2), 152-157.
3. Mackinnon, L. T., Chronic exercise training effects on immune function. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 2000, 32 (7), 369-376.

Connect with Jeff Gaudette on Google+

4 Responses on “How Does Running Affect Your Immune System? The Research on Illness, Part II

  1. Thank you for this overview. The next question then is how to decrease the chances of getting an infection. You mention basic hygiene but is there more to be done in fuelling the body so as to reduce the occurrences of post marathon or longer illness.

    • Hi Dave, great point. Fueling correctly definitely plays a huge role in preventing illness. We have a lot of great articles to help you with this. BY fueling with the right foods, your immune system will be better equipped to fight off sickness to allow you to keep training. Hopefully some of these articles will answer your questions, especially if you look at the recovery articles https://runnersconnect.net/nutrition-for-runners/. Hope this helps!

  2. Hi Dave Thanks for the article. Some anecdotal evidence from me to back this up. I have been off work today (Wed) with what feels like proper flu. This began with a runny nose Sun Eve having run a Half Marathon that day. I don’t usually race two weeks in a row but had run a hard 10K race the previous Sun. That had followed a hard interval session the previous Tue. I knew I was stretching myself but had been running well. Travelling on public transport daily, catching a virus is a bit of a lottery but having not had a cold in 15 months I can’t help but think the increase in intensity made my immune system more vulnerable. Lesson learned!

    • Hi Ian, thanks for sharing your story. Sorry to hear you are going through some form of the flu, but you are right, there are general ways to try to avoid it, but there is often a good deal of luck involved. Running hard will certainly put you at a greater risk. Hope you feel better!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Adding new comments is only available for RunnersConnect Insider members.



Already a member? Login here

Want to become an Insider for free? Register here