John Davis

Written by John Davis

2 COMMENTS

Can You Train Your Lungs and Breathing Muscles to Get Stronger and Will this Actually Help You Run Faster

It’s hard to imagine something as fundamental to running as breathing.  You really can’t go without it! But as simple as breathing is, there are still a lot of questions about how it actually affects your running.

Can getting better at breathing—with stronger lungs and breathing muscles—actually make you a better runner?

How much does your ability to breathe to the fullest extent possible actually impact your performance?

These issues have obvious implications on training and racing; there are even companies which advertise respiration-muscle training devices to strengthen the muscles that help you inhale and exhale.

To get to the bottom of all this, we’ll have to take a look at some of the research that’s been done on respiration, ventilation muscles, and running.

Respiratory muscle fatigue and performance

Your actual inhalation and exhalation during running is controlled by your respiratory muscles: primarily your diaphragm, the sheet-like muscle that lies just below your lungs, but also some of the muscles surrounding the inside of your ribcage. Like any other muscle in the body, these should become stronger with training.

Whether specific training can strengthen these muscles isn’t our real concern, however; it’s whether it is beneficial to strengthen them to improve performance.  In other words, are these muscles a rate-limiting factor in an endurance sport like running?

Answering that should be reasonably straightforward with a well-designed study.  If the respiratory muscles become fatigued after intense exercise, it’s possible that strengthening them could lead to increased performance.  A few studies have examined respiratory muscle fatigue following exercise, with mixed results.

Maximum voluntary ventilation and VO2 max test

A small study in 1982 measured several factors related to respiratory muscle strength in four runners before and after completing a marathon at about 7:50 mile pace.  The authors noted decreases in the runners’ ability to exert pressure while breathing in and out, as well as decreases in their maximum voluntary ventilation, a metric which examines the maximum amount of air you can move in and out of your lungs in one minute.

Another study, published in 1993 by researchers at the University of Wisconsin, conducted a similar experiment on 12 people, ranging from modestly fit recreational athletes to extremely well-conditioned runners.  They too found that the respiratory muscles could become fatigued after a hard effort (this time, a VO2 max test on a treadmill to exhaustion).  These results seem to indicate that respiratory fatigue is indeed a real phenomenon after a hard effort.

Inducing respiratory fatigue through hard effort

However, other research has not been able to induce respiratory muscle fatigue, even after exercise of similar difficulty.  Nava et al. published a study in 1992 which found no evidence of respiratory muscle fatigue in six well-trained runners who completed a 10.5-mile time trial at an all-out effort, and a 1999 study out of the University of Zurich in Switzerland was only able to detect respiratory fatigue after a hard cycling test when the subjects had to breathe against mechanical resistance—something that doesn’t happen in the real world.

So it is still unclear to what extent, if any, a well-trained runner will experience respiratory muscle fatigue during or after a hard effort.  Nava et al. speculate that fatigue of the respiratory muscles might only be observed in less-trained athletes.

Respiratory muscle strength and performance

Indeed, other research has shown that running training itself will increase respiratory muscle strength, including many of the ventilation-related variables measured in the studies above.  But the question still remains as to whether independently strengthening the respiratory muscles with specific training will have any impact on performance.

Using muscle training device

Fortunately, this very topic was addressed in a 2000 paper published by Omri Inbar and others at the Wingate Institute in Israel.  Twenty well-trained runners, all of whom had competed nationally in track events, were split into two groups.  The first received a specialized respiratory muscle training device, which was fitted over the mouth and provided adjustable resistance to inhalation.

Under the supervision of a physiotherapist, the subjects used it to strengthen their respiratory muscles six times per week in thirty-minute sessions during the ten-week study.  The control group received the same device, but it was modified to provide no resistance during breathing, functioning as a “sham treatment.” At the conclusion of the study, the subjects underwent another session of exercise testing, just as they had done at the outset.

While the strength of their respiratory muscles did increase when the runners in the experimental group were breathing against resistance, this did not translate into a higher VO2 max, aerobic capacity, or amount of oxygen transported into the blood via the lungs when compared to the control group.

So, while specific training for the muscles which control inhalation and exhalation during running does strengthen them, it doesn’t seem to have an effect on your actual performance while running.

This is likely because access to oxygen in the lungs isn’t usually a limiting factor in endurance athletes—by the time your blood leaves your lungs, it is already fully saturated with oxygen from the air.  This is also why accessories which claim to increase airflow to your lungs (like Breathe Right strips) won’ t help your performance either.

Conclusion

It appears that there is no need to worry about specific strength training for your breathing muscles, since running training by itself will strengthen your lungs, and because of the questionable existence of respiratory muscle fatigue after hard efforts, especially in well-trained runners, the strength of your lungs shouldn’t be something that will hold you back in training or in racing.

Two notable exceptions do exist, however: exercise-induced asthma and altitude.  During an asthma attack, your airways become so restricted that your blood can’t get enough oxygen, hindering performance.  Likewise, at altitudes above about 3200′, the air pressure is too low to allow your blood to fully saturate with oxygen.  Of course, the muscles that you use to breathe aren’t the root of the problem in either of these cases!

Fortunately, breathing is something you can mostly forget about when you run.  There’s no evidence that you need to pay special attention to your breathing muscles when you are training, which is good given the multitude of other things you have to worry about.

RunnersConnect Insider Bonus

Download your FREE breathing guide for Runners inside your Insider Members area.

It’s a PDF with images and descriptions of the most effective pilates exercises to strengthen your body while relaxing your mind.

Click here to access

Not a RunnersConnect Insider member? It’s FREE to join. Click here to get started

Free Run Faster Course

Learn How to Train Smarter and Run Faster Using the Latest Science and Proven Workouts

Here’s what you'll learn in this course

The scientific demands of your race distance so you know exactly how to target your workouts and training.

6 Race specific workouts that will help up you crush your next race

The most common mistakes you're making in training and in your race plan (and how to fix them)

References

1. Loke, J.; Mahler, D.; Virgulto, J., Respiratory muscle fatigue after marathon running. Journal of Applied Physiology 1982, 52 (4), 821-824.
2. Johnson, B. D.; Babcock, M. A.; Suman, O. E.; Dempsey, J. A., Exercise-induced diaphragmatic fatigue in healthy humans. Journal of Physiology 1993, 460, 385-405.
3. Nava, S.; Zanotti, E.; Rampulla, C.; Rossi, A., Respiratory muscle fatigue does not limit exercise performance during moderate endurance run. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 1992, 32 (1), 39-44.
4. Perret, C.; Pfeiffer, R.; Boutellier, U.; Wey, H.; Spengler, C., Noninvasive measurement of respiratory muscle performance after exhaustive endurance exercise. European Respiratory Journal 1999, 14, 264-269.
5. Robinson, E.; Kjeldgaard, J., Improvement in ventilatory muscle function with running. Journal of Applied Physiology 1982, 52 (6), 1400-1406.
6. Inbar, O.; Weiner, P.; Azgad, Y.; Rotstein, A.; Weinstein, Y., Specific inspiratory muscle training in well-trained endurance athletes. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 2000, 32 (7), 1233-1237.
7. Geelhoed, G. C.; Landau, L. I.; LeSouëf, P. N., Predictive value of oxygen saturation in emergency evaluation of asthmatic children. British Medical Journal 1988, 6, 395-396.
8. West, J. B.; Lahiri, S.; Milledge, J.; Pugh, L. G. C. E.; Ward, M., Arterial oxygen saturation during exercise at high altitude. Journal of Applied Physiology 1962, 17 (4), 617-621.

Connect with Jeff Gaudette on Google+

2 Responses on “Can You Train Your Lungs and Breathing Muscles to Get Stronger and Will this Actually Help You Run Faster

  1. Hi i have sarcodosis and it causes me to get out of breath fast plus i used to smoke. I would like to no ways i can make my lungs stronger,so i dont get out of breath so fast. I want to bad àble to run again and play football and basketball. At this point i get out of breath fast

    • It will come, just be patient, and allow your body to make the fitness gains in its own time. You will be surprised how quickly your lungs will adjust to running. The points in this article should help you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Adding new comments is only available for RunnersConnect Insider members.



Already a member? Login here

Want to become an Insider for free? Register here