What Do Insoles Do? 4 Types and Which One You Need

Jeff Gaudette, MS   |

Insoles change the forces on your foot and leg far more than they change your foot’s alignment, which can explain why the same pair helps some runners and not others.

The 4 main types of insoles are cushioned or shock-absorbing insoles, prefabricated arch support insoles, heat-moldable insoles and custom orthotics.

In a 2017 meta-analysis, foot orthoses lowered the risk of any injury by 28% and of stress fractures by 41%, while shock-absorbing insoles did not prevent injuries.

Runners with pronated feet in neutral shoes were not injured more often than runners with neutral feet, so foot type alone is a weak reason to buy insoles.

For plantar fasciitis, firm off-the-shelf and custom orthoses worked equally well, so try a firm prefabricated insole first and choose the pair that feels most comfortable when you run.

If you’ve bought running shoes at a specialty store, you’ve probably been offered a pair of insoles to go with them.

The pitch often follows a pressure-plate test that labels your arches as high, low or neutral.

Insoles do change what happens inside your shoe, but mostly in a different way than the sales pitch claims.

They change the forces on your foot and leg far more than they change the shape or alignment of your foot.

That’s why the same pair can help one runner and do nothing for another.

Here’s what you’ll learn about choosing insoles for running:

  • What insoles change when your foot hits the ground
  • The 4 main types of insoles and how they differ
  • Whether insoles prevent injuries or help an existing one heal
  • When custom orthotics are worth the extra money, and how to pick a pair yourself

What Do Insoles Do When You Run?

An insole changes how force travels through your foot and leg each time you land, and it does very little to reposition your foot.

A 2010 review of 22 studies found that flat orthoses with an inner-edge wedge reduced how far the heel rolled inward by only about 2 degrees.

Molded orthoses, on the other hand, produced large drops in impact force and in how quickly that force hit the leg.

A 2-degree shift is a small change in how your foot moves.

So when an insole helps, it’s more likely because it changed the load on your foot and leg than because it changed how your foot moves.

That also explains why results vary so much from runner to runner.

A change in load that takes pressure off one runner’s sore heel can also shift stress somewhere else.

What Are the Different Types of Insoles?

Insoles and shoe inserts fall into 4 main groups, and they differ in how firm they are and how closely they’re shaped to your foot.

Cushioned or Shock-Absorbing Insoles

These are soft foam or gel inserts that replace the thin liner that came with your shoe.

They add softness underfoot but have little shape and no arch support.

Prefabricated Arch Support Insoles

These off-the-shelf insoles have a firmer shell with a molded arch and heel cup, and they’re usually sold in low, medium and high arch versions.

These are the insoles you’ll see most often on the wall at a running store.

Heat-Moldable Insoles

A heat-moldable insole starts as an off-the-shelf insole that a store heats and presses against your foot so it takes on your foot’s shape.

The material and firmness are the same for every runner, so the fit changes but the type of support doesn’t.

Custom Orthotics

Custom orthotics are made for one person by a podiatrist or orthotist from a scan or cast of your foot.

The clinician chooses the shape, the stiffness and the wedging based on your foot and your injury, and that design can change as the injury improves.

Infographic of the 4 types of insoles: cushioned, arch support, heat-moldable and custom orthotic, from softer and generic to firmer and personalized

Whichever type you choose, the insole changes how your foot sits inside the shoe, and the way you lace the shoe changes that fit too.

RunnersConnect Bonus

Download your FREE lacing techniques guide.

You know how to read the wear of shoes, but are you lacing your shoes wrong? Download our Running Shoe Lacing guide for free and get a quick reminder, specific how-to and resources for videos on the best way to lace your running shoes.

GET MY GUIDE

Do Insoles Prevent Running Injuries?

A firm, shaped insert can reduce your chance of getting injured, but a soft gel insole won’t.

research
A 2017 meta-analysis of 11 foot orthosis trials and 7 shock-absorbing insole trials found that foot orthoses lowered the risk of any injury by 28% and the risk of stress fractures by 41%, while shock-absorbing insoles did not lower the risk of any injury.

The orthoses did not clearly lower the risk of soft-tissue injuries such as strains and tendon problems.

That means a pair of soft gel inserts is unlikely to reduce your chance of getting injured, whatever the packaging says about absorbing impact.

If you want an insert that protects you from injury, choose a shaped orthosis, since that’s where the evidence is, mostly for stress fractures.

Bar chart showing foot orthoses lowered the risk of any injury by 28 percent and stress fractures by 41 percent, while shock-absorbing insoles had no clear effect

Do You Need Insoles Because of Your Arch Height or Pronation?

Your arch height or how much your foot rolls inward is a weak reason to buy insoles on its own.

Running stores have sorted runners by arch height for decades, on the theory that a foot that rolls in too far or too little causes injuries.

research
A 2014 study that followed 927 new runners in neutral shoes for a year found that runners with pronated feet had no higher risk of injury after 155 miles (250 km) than runners with neutral feet, and had fewer injuries for every 621 miles (1,000 km) they ran.

The study had too few runners with the flattest or highest-arched feet to say whether those extreme foot types carry more risk.

A 2015 review of running shoe and injury research found no conclusive evidence that pronation or impact forces predict running injuries.

So if a store recommends insoles because of a wet-foot test or a pressure-plate reading, and you have no pain, you can skip them.

Can Insoles Help With a Running Injury?

Insoles can ease pain from some running injuries within the first 6 to 12 weeks.

research
A 2011 trial of 99 runners with chronic overuse injuries found that the 51 runners who wore custom semi-rigid foam orthoses for 8 weeks reported less pain and less disability than the 48 who kept training with no treatment.

Their comfort rating for the orthoses rose from 69 to 83 points on a 100-point scale over those 8 weeks.

The control group got no insole at all, so part of the drop in pain could come from receiving any treatment at all.

For runner’s knee, a 2008 trial of 179 people with pain around the kneecap found that off-the-shelf orthoses helped more than flat inserts at 6 weeks.

The people who did 6 weeks of physical therapy improved as much as the people with orthoses, and adding orthoses to the therapy didn’t help further.

That therapy included quad retraining, taping and kneecap mobilization.

That means physical therapy that included quad work helped runner’s knee as much as insoles did, so insoles aren’t your only option.

If you want a structured plan for that quad work, our Strength Training for Runners program has routines built for runners, with protocols for the injuries runners get most.

Are Custom Insoles Worth It for Runners?

For plantar fasciitis, a firm off-the-shelf insole works about as well as a custom orthotic.

research
A 2006 trial of 135 people with plantar fasciitis found that a firm foam off-the-shelf orthosis and a custom plastic orthosis improved foot function scores by about 8 points out of 100 compared with a thin foam sham at 3 months, and the 3 groups were no different at 12 months.

The off-the-shelf and custom orthoses worked equally well at both time points.

That means you can start with a firm prefabricated insole and see if it helps before you pay for a custom pair.

You can read how to treat and prevent plantar fasciitis with the steps that work alongside an insole.

RunnersConnect Insider Bonus

Download our Plantar Fascia Treatment Outline.

It’s a PDF with an outline of the conservative and aggressive treatment options to help you get through your plantar fasciitis.

GET MY GUIDE

v

A custom orthotic makes more sense when off-the-shelf insoles haven’t helped, when your foot shape doesn’t fit standard insoles, or when a podiatrist is treating a specific injury.

For a closer look at the fitting process, read about when runners need custom orthotics and what to expect from a fitting.

How Do You Choose the Right Insoles for Running?

Choose insoles by how they feel when you run, because comfort is the guide the research points to.

The same 2015 review proposed that runners pick the shoes and inserts that feel comfortable, and that a comfortable choice lets them keep their natural stride.

A 2023 meta-analysis of footwear comfort found that runners used less oxygen at the same speed in their most comfortable footwear.

The drop was about 2 mL per kilogram of body weight per minute compared with their least comfortable footwear.

Some insoles can also make running cost more energy.

A 2019 review of 9 studies, 5 of them on foot orthoses, found that orthoses had a small negative effect on running economy on average compared with running without them.

If an insole doesn’t feel more comfortable than your shoe’s original liner within the first 2 weeks, it isn’t the right insole for you.

Use these steps to test a pair:

  1. Try them in your own running shoes. Remove the original liner and check that the insole sits flat without crowding your toes or lifting your heel out of the shoe.
  2. Jog in them before you buy. Pick the pair that feels best while moving, since standing comfort doesn’t always match running comfort.
  3. Build up gradually. Start with your easy runs and wear them for 1 to 2 weeks before using them for long runs or workouts.
  4. Watch for new aches. Stop using them if new pain shows up in your arch, knee or hip.
  5. See a professional for pain that lasts. Book a podiatrist or physical therapist if pain persists beyond a few days or keeps coming back.

The table below compares each type of insole.

Insole type What it does What the research found
Cushioned or shock-absorbing Adds softness underfoot Did not lower injury risk
Prefabricated arch support Firm shell with a molded arch and heel cup Matched custom orthotics for plantar fasciitis and helped runner’s knee at 6 weeks
Heat-moldable Off-the-shelf insole shaped to your foot in the store Not tested in the trials above
Custom orthotic Shape and stiffness chosen by a clinician Reduced pain from overuse injuries at 8 weeks, no better than a sham insole at 12 months
What do insoles do for runners?

Insoles change how force travels through your foot and leg each time you land. A 2010 review of 22 studies found that wedged orthoses reduced how far the heel rolled inward by only about 2 degrees, while molded orthoses produced large drops in impact force and loading rate. That means insoles likely help by changing the load on your foot and leg rather than by realigning it, which can explain why the same pair helps one runner and not another.

Do insoles really work?

Some do, depending on the type and what you want them to do. In a 2017 meta-analysis, foot orthoses lowered the risk of any injury by 28% and of stress fractures by 41%. Shock-absorbing insoles did not lower the risk of any injury. For an existing injury, orthoses improved pain or function over the first 6 to 12 weeks in trials of runner’s knee, plantar fasciitis and chronic overuse injuries in runners.

What are the different types of insoles?

The 4 main types are cushioned or shock-absorbing insoles, prefabricated arch support insoles, heat-moldable insoles and custom orthotics. Cushioned insoles add softness with no arch shape. Prefabricated insoles have a firm shell with a molded arch and heel cup. Heat-moldable insoles are off-the-shelf insoles shaped to your foot in the store, and custom orthotics are designed by a podiatrist or orthotist from a scan or cast of your foot.

How do I know what insoles I need?

Start with comfort and your reason for buying them. If you have no pain, a foot-type test alone is a weak reason to buy insoles, because a year-long study of 927 new runners found pronated feet were not injured more often than neutral feet. If you have heel, arch or knee pain, try a firm prefabricated insole in your own shoes and pick the pair that feels best while you jog.

Do I need insoles if I overpronate?

Not necessarily. In a 2014 study that followed 927 new runners in neutral shoes for a year, runners with pronated feet had no higher injury risk after 155 miles (250 km) than runners with neutral feet. A 2015 review found no conclusive evidence that pronation predicts running injuries. Insoles make more sense when you have pain, and a podiatrist can help if your feet are very flat.

Are custom insoles worth it for running?

For most runners, try off-the-shelf insoles first. In a 2006 trial of 135 people with plantar fasciitis, firm prefabricated orthoses and custom orthoses improved function by similar amounts at 3 months, and neither beat a sham insole at 12 months. A custom pair makes more sense when off-the-shelf insoles haven’t helped, your foot shape doesn’t fit standard insoles, or a podiatrist is treating a specific injury.

Can insoles make running worse?

They can. A 2019 review of 9 studies, 5 of them on foot orthoses, found that orthoses had a small negative effect on running economy on average, meaning you use more energy at the same pace. Insoles also shift load, so a pair that relieves one area can add stress to another. Build up wear over 1 to 2 weeks on easy runs, and stop if new pain shows up in your arch, knee or hip.

Jeff Gaudette, M.S. Johns Hopkins University

Jeff is the co-founder of RunnersConnect and a former Olympic Trials qualifier.

He began coaching in 2005 and has had success at all levels of coaching; high school, college, local elite, and everyday runners.

Under his tutelage, hundreds of runners have finished their first marathon and he’s helped countless runners qualify for Boston.

He's spent the last 15 years breaking down complicated training concepts into actionable advice for everyday runners. His writings and research can be found in journals, magazines and across the web.

Bonanno, Daniel R., et al. “Effectiveness of Foot Orthoses and Shock-Absorbing Insoles for the Prevention of Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” British Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. 51, no. 2, 2017, pp. 86-96.

Collins, Natalie, et al. “Foot Orthoses and Physiotherapy in the Treatment of Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome: Randomised Clinical Trial.” BMJ, vol. 337, 2008, a1735.

Crago, Daniel, Chris Bishop, and John B. Arnold. “The Effect of Foot Orthoses and Insoles on Running Economy and Performance in Distance Runners: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” Journal of Sports Sciences, vol. 37, no. 22, 2019, pp. 2613-2624.

Hirschmüller, Anja, et al. “Clinical Effectiveness of Customised Sport Shoe Orthoses for Overuse Injuries in Runners: A Randomised Controlled Study.” British Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. 45, no. 12, 2011, pp. 959-965.

Landorf, Karl B., Anne-Maree Keenan, and Robert D. Herbert. “Effectiveness of Foot Orthoses to Treat Plantar Fasciitis: A Randomized Trial.” Archives of Internal Medicine, vol. 166, no. 12, 2006, pp. 1305-1310.

Mills, Kathryn, et al. “Foot Orthoses and Gait: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Literature Pertaining to Potential Mechanisms.” British Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. 44, no. 14, 2010, pp. 1035-1046.

Nielsen, Rasmus Oestergaard, et al. “Foot Pronation Is Not Associated with Increased Injury Risk in Novice Runners Wearing a Neutral Shoe: A 1-Year Prospective Cohort Study.” British Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. 48, no. 6, 2014, pp. 440-447.

Nigg, Benno M., et al. “Running Shoes and Running Injuries: Mythbusting and a Proposal for Two New Paradigms: ‘Preferred Movement Path’ and ‘Comfort Filter’.” British Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. 49, no. 20, 2015, pp. 1290-1294.

Van Alsenoy, Ken, et al. “Increased Footwear Comfort Is Associated with Improved Running Economy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” European Journal of Sport Science, vol. 23, no. 1, 2023, pp. 121-133.

Picture of Who We Are

Who We Are

Your team of expert coaches and fellow runners dedicated to helping you train smarter, stay healthy and run faster.

We love running and want to spread our expertise and passion to inspire, motivate, and help you achieve your running goals.

6 Responses

    1. Hey Tim, many thanks for the comment. Good to hear you enjoyed it! Full credit must go to my sources Ian Griffiths & Craig Payne though as they have both played a huge part in bringing not just me but many other therapists & coaches up to date with what is definately a hotly debated and often misinterprated area of study & research.

  1. While I am not a doctor, I have been a “patient” wearing custom orthotics for more than 10 years in my running shoes. If you’ll allow me to share my experience, I would not be running without them.

    Thirty years ago, I was a sub 5 miler and 60 pounds lighter. When I decided to pick up running again, I went to Boston Pedorthic (now in Chestnut Hill, MA). My goal was to be sure my body was in balance during my runs. They performed a gait analysis, took pressure density measurements of my feet walking across the room and running on a treadmill, scanned my feet, and recommended shoes with extra depth for running. I have been running in Brooks Adrenaline ever since. The inserts they created on their 3d mill are a perfect fit for my feet and shoe with different durometer (density) to match the support where I need it.

    My physician wrote a prescription for them without hesitation.

    The only thing I would have done differently from the start is the treadmill. Pride made me run on the treadmill at 9.0 mph when my training pace was more like a 9 minute mile. If I were to start again, I would create one for training and one for speed work/racing. Until I came back for adjustments my speed inserts had too much arch for my training pace. I’ve seen people put the feet into Boston Pedorthic inserts for the first time and a smile to brighten a room came across their face. It’s worth the trip!

  2. “…orthoses do not need to significantly alter joint alignment (kinematics) in order to reduce forces (kinetics).” Similarly, it would seem, do minor changes in gait. Many would claim that poor form and/or weakness’s in the leg and hip muscles are responsible for poor alignment and subsequent injuries in the knees, feet, ankles, etc. Using orthoses might give relief whilst leaving the original inadequacies in place. Food for thought 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *